Common Insurance Claim Mistakes After Water Damage
Water damage in a home requiring an insurance claim
Insurance

Common Insurance Claim Mistakes After Water Damage

5 min read Five Star Restoration Team July 2026

Water damage can wreak havoc on your home in a matter of minutes. Once you have stopped the water at the source, your next priority is to file an insurance claim.

In any given year, around 1.67% of insured homes file a water damage claim. Unfortunately, many insured homeowners make simple, preventable mistakes during the claims process that often lead to delays, reduced payouts, or even denied claims.

Knowing what to avoid can make a stressful situation much easier.

Waiting Too Long to Report the Damage

One of the biggest mistakes homeowners make is waiting to file their insurance claim. Even if the damage seems small, water can quickly seep into:

  • Walls
  • Flooring
  • Insulation

This leads to hidden issues like mold growth and structural damage.

Contact your insurance company as soon as possible after discovering the damage. Most policies require prompt reporting, and waiting too long could complicate your claim.

Pro Tip

Report the damage immediately, even if you are still assessing the extent of the problem. You can always provide additional information later.

Failing to Document Everything

Insurance adjusters depend on detailed documentation to determine the value of your claim. Without clear evidence, it may be difficult to prove the full extent of the water damage.

Be sure to:

  • Take photos and videos before cleanup begins
  • Document damaged belongings
  • Save receipts for emergency repairs and temporary lodging if applicable
  • Keep records of every conversation with your insurance company

The more organized your records are, the easier the claims process will be.

Pro Tip

Create a dedicated folder, digital or physical, to keep all claim-related documents in one place.

Homeowner documenting water damage with a phone for insurance claim
Thorough photo and video documentation before cleanup begins is critical to supporting your insurance claim.

Starting Major Repairs Too Soon

It is important to prevent additional damage, but you do not want to greenlight major restoration work until your insurance company has had an opportunity to inspect the property.

You should:

  • Perform emergency mitigation, such as water extraction or tarping
  • Avoid removing heavily damaged materials unless necessary for safety
  • Wait for approval before making permanent repairs whenever possible

A professional restoration company like Five Star Restoration understands how to balance emergency mitigation with insurance requirements.

Pro Tip

Emergency water mitigation is usually encouraged because it helps prevent further damage, but always document the condition before work begins.

Need help with water damage and insurance?

We document the damage, handle the mitigation, and work directly with your adjuster.

Throwing Away Damaged Items

It may be tempting to get rid of soaked furniture, carpeting, or personal belongings immediately. However, these items often serve as evidence during the claims process.

Unless they present a health hazard:

  • Photograph every damaged item
  • Create a detailed inventory
  • Wait until your adjuster authorizes disposal

This simple step can help ensure you receive proper compensation.

Pro Tip

Label damaged items with photos and notes so they are easy to identify during the inspection.

Do Not Let Small Mistakes Cost You Big

Water damage claims do not have to be major headaches. By reporting the damage quickly, documenting everything thoroughly, avoiding premature repairs, and preserving damaged belongings, you will put yourself in the best position for a successful claim.

If your home has experienced water damage, our experienced team can help with emergency water extraction, drying, cleanup, and insurance claim documentation. Contact Five Star Restoration today to restore your property quickly and help simplify the insurance claims process.

Available 24/7

Need Water Damage Restoration?

We handle the mitigation, the repairs, and the insurance paperwork. Call us now or request an estimate.

(844) 747-2110 Get Free Estimate →

No obligation. Crews available 24 hours a day.



Water Damage? We Handle the Restoration and the Paperwork.

Tell us what happened. We will call you back quickly to get started.

Request Emergency Help

Fill this out and a team member will call you back, usually within 15 minutes.

We never share your information. No spam, ever.

What Happens Next

1
We Call You Back

A team member reaches out within 15 minutes to understand the damage and confirm your location.

2
We Document and Extract

We photograph the damage for your claim, then begin water extraction and structural drying immediately.

3
We Work With Your Insurance

We prepare the damage report, communicate with your adjuster, and help keep your claim moving forward.

4
We Restore Your Property

From emergency mitigation through full repairs, one team handles everything start to finish.

Prefer to call directly?

(844) 747-2110

Available 24/7. No obligation.